Pension Transfers
Introduction
Pension transfers are a common feature of retirement planning, allowing pension rights to move from one scheme to another. While transfers can provide access to different investment options, retirement benefits, and service propositions, they are governed by detailed legislative and tax rules.
This briefing outlines the key transfer principles contained within HMRC's Pensions Tax Manual and highlights the technical considerations advisers should understand when discussing transfers with clients.
Core considerations
-
A transfer involves the movement of pension rights from one pension scheme to another.
-
To avoid unauthorised payment tax charges, transfers must satisfy the conditions for a recognised transfer.
-
Pension rights do not have to be transferred before benefits are taken; certain pensions in payment can also be transferred, provided specific conditions are met.
-
Transfers can result in the loss of protections, including protected pension ages and scheme-specific tax-free cash protections.
-
Block transfers can retain protections in a receiving scheme, so long as the conditions can be met.
-
A transfer is generally not treated as a pension contribution.
-
Partial transfers may be available from some schemes but are not permissible for drawdown funds.
Contents
- What is a pension transfer?
- Common reasons to transfer
- Statutory transfer rights
- Recognised transfers
- Individual and block transfers
- Tax treatment of transfers
- Forms of transfer
- When can a transfer occur?
- Transfers of drawdown pensions
- Protections and transfer considerations
- Transferring while in poor health
- Cancellation rights
What is a pension transfer?
At its simplest, a pension transfer is the movement of pension rights from one pension scheme to another.
When a transfer takes place, the rights and assets supporting a member's benefits move from the transferring scheme to a receiving scheme. Once the transfer has been completed, the receiving scheme becomes responsible for administering and ultimately paying the member's benefits, subject to its own rules and available benefit options.
These rights are generally exercised through a Cash Equivalent Transfer Value (CETV), which represents the capital value of the member's accrued pension rights. The CETV allows benefits to be transferred from one pension scheme to another in exchange for an equivalent value of assets.
Legislation exists largely to ensure that pension assets remain within the pensions environment and continue to be used to provide retirement benefits.
Common reasons to transfer
Common reasons for transferring include:
- A member wishing to consolidate benefits from a range of pension schemes.
- To gain access to different retirement income options.
- To gain access to a wider range of pension death benefits.
- Access to wider investment options or lower charges.
- The transfer of pension rights awarded through a pension sharing order.
- The winding up of an occupational pension scheme.
- Clients moving overseas or those moving back to the UK.
Statutory transfer rights
Many members have legal rights to transfer benefits under pensions legislation. The existence of a statutory right does not automatically mean a transfer qualifies as a recognised transfer for tax purposes. HMRC's tax rules continue to apply independently of pensions legislation.
Scheme administrator considerations
The transferring scheme must establish whether the statutory transfer conditions have been satisfied. TPR guidance explicitly requires trustees and administrators to:
- Collect information relating to the receiving scheme.
- Assess evidence supplied by the member.
- Identify statutory red flags and amber flags.
- Determine whether the statutory transfer right exists.
Where certain risk indicators are identified schemes may require members to obtain scam guidance or may refuse transfers.
Key due diligence checks involve assessment of:
- Failure to provide information.
- Identifying unregulated financial advisers.
- High pressure sales tactics.
- Suspected scam activity.
- Employment links to a receiving scheme.
Recognised transfers
HMRC places particular emphasis on the destination of the transferred assets. A recognised transfer allows pension rights to move between schemes without triggering unauthorised payment tax charges. Even where a member has a statutory transfer right, a transfer that fails to meet the recognised transfer rules would result in unauthorised payment charges.
Broadly speaking, HMRC requires pension savings to remain within a recognised pensions framework and continue to be held for the purpose of providing retirement benefits for the transferring individual.
For a transfer to be recognised:
- The funds must continue to be held for the member's pension benefits.
- The transfer must be made to another registered pension scheme or a Qualifying Recognised Overseas Pension Scheme (QROPS).
Transfers into the Pension Protection Fund (PPF) or Financial Assistance Scheme (FAS) are also recognised transfers.
This principle is straightforward but becomes important where complex arrangements are involved. For example, a transfer payment made directly to an individual or a non-pension vehicle is unlikely to satisfy the recognised transfer conditions – as such most schemes will not permit a transfer that does not meet recognised transfer conditions. Though certain transfers to insurance companies will be recognised transfers if the funds are used to purchase a scheme pension.
It is also important to remember that a member's right to request a transfer is not the same as a receiving scheme's obligation to accept one. Most schemes can decide whether they wish to receive a transfer. Due diligence, administrative requirements, anti-money laundering procedures and provider business practices may all influence whether a transfer is accepted.
Stakeholder pension schemes
Stakeholder pension schemes are one of the few exceptions, as legislation generally requires them to accept transfers from other registered pension schemes.
Where pensions already in payment are being transferred, further conditions must be met before the transfer can be treated as recognised.
Partial transfers
Many pension schemes permit partial transfers, allowing a member to move some of their pension benefits to another scheme while retaining the remainder in the existing scheme. Whether a partial transfer is available will depend on the rules of the transferring schemes, and the type of benefits being transferred.
Members may have a statutory right to transfer one category of benefits while leaving another category behind. For example, a member could transfer their defined contribution benefits to another scheme and retain their defined benefit entitlement in the existing scheme, or vice versa.
Individual and block transfers
When transferring pension benefits, it is important to distinguish between an individual transfer and a block transfer. Both can be recognised transfers for tax purposes, but the distinction is particularly important where a member has valuable protections, such as:
- Scheme-specific tax-free cash protection.
- Stand-alone lump sum protection.
- Protected pension ages.
The type of transfer can determine whether these protections are retained or lost.
Individual transfers
An individual transfer occurs where a single member's pension rights are transferred independently of other members. This is the most common form of pension transfer and may be either a full or (where scheme rules permit) a partial transfer.
Individual transfers do not protect scheme specific tax-free cash or stand-alone lump sum protection – such benefits are lost on transfer.
Pre age 55 protected pension ages are lost on transfer, however age 55-57 protected pension ages are retained as part of an individual transfer. The receiving scheme must ringfence the transferred in funds with age 55-57 protection so any growth on that portion of the member’s benefits will retain the early protection age, any other benefits won’t be available until the normal minimum pension age (unless otherwise benefitting from a different protected age).
Read our briefing on Pension Age for more details of how protected pension ages are treated on individual and block transfer.
Block transfers
A block transfer is a special type of pension transfer that allows valuable protections to be retained when pension benefits are moved to another scheme.
For a transfer to qualify as a block transfer, several conditions must normally be met:
- The client and at least one other scheme member must transfer from the same transferring scheme.
- The transferring members must move their rights into the same receiving scheme as a single transaction.
- The transfer had to comprise all rights under the transferring scheme relating to the members participating in the block transfer. Partial transfers will not meet this requirement.
Block transfers are particularly important for members with pre 6 April 2006 scheme-specific tax-free cash protection, where their protected entitlement exceeds 25% of their pension benefits. A block transfer allows this protection to be retained in the receiving scheme.
Where a scheme with scheme-specific tax-free cash protection is block transferred into a receiving scheme that does not already have such protection, the protected tax-free cash entitlement is preserved. The scheme-specific tax-free cash formula then applies to the combined value of the member's benefits in the receiving arrangement. The other non-protected benefits do not increase the protected A-Day amount used in the formula, those benefits can generally support tax-free cash of up to 25% of their value through the scheme-specific tax-free cash calculation.
Because the entire tax-free lump sum is paid under the scheme-specific tax-free cash calculation, there can be advantages. In particular, scheme-specific tax-free cash is not restricted by the individual's Lump Sum Allowance (LSA). By contrast, if the protected and non-protected benefits were taken separately, the tax-free cash attributable to the non-protected benefits would normally be subject to the LSA limit.
Additionally, protected pension ages are protected as part of a block transfer, and typically are extended to all benefits in the receiving scheme.
Where clients hold pensions in individual arrangements such as a S32 buy out bond, S226 retirement annuities or single member SSAS then as there is only a single member in the scheme, it’s not possible to complete a block transfer.
Tax treatment of transfers
Transfers out
Provided the transfer is a recognised transfer, the transaction will generally be treated as an authorised payment – typically with no tax charge.
Where a transfer fails to satisfy the recognised transfer conditions, the consequences can be severe. The transfer may be treated as an unauthorised payment, triggering tax charges for the member and potentially scheme sanction charges for the scheme administrator.
Certain transfers involving overseas pension arrangements may also be subject to the Overseas Transfer Charge.
Transfers in
A transfer is not normally treated as a contribution to a pension, the member is not making a new personal contribution and no new tax relief arises merely because funds have changed schemes. Instead, the transfer represents the continuation of existing pension rights within a different arrangement. This distinction is important when considering annual allowance calculations, contribution limits and the overall taxation of pension savings.
Forms of transfer
The usual way of making pension transfers is for the investments under the transferring scheme to be encashed and then the cash is transferred to the receiving scheme. However, there are other options, transfers may occur:
- In cash.
- By transferring assets in specie.
- By assignment of insurance policies.
Whatever the form of assets being transferred a CETV will be established to ensure rights of equal value are received in the receiving scheme.
In specie transfers
An alternative to the traditional cash transfer is an in-specie transfer - where assets are transferred directly from one pension scheme to another. In specie transfers may be particularly relevant where schemes hold commercial property, quoted securities, insured funds, or other assets that can be moved directly rather than sold and repurchased. This can be particularly beneficial where current valuations are low, assets may be difficult to sell at short notice or where surrender penalties may apply.
Where assets are transferred in specie, they must be appropriately valued. HMRC expects assets to be valued on a cash basis by a suitably qualified independent person. This helps ensure the transfer accurately reflects the value of the rights being moved and prevents manipulation of pension values.
As a result, whilst members may think simply in terms of "moving a pension", the actual transfer process can involve complex asset valuation and ownership considerations. But it's not a given that an in-specie transfer will be an option. Some pension schemes can't, or simply won't, accept some types of asset, and some won’t accept in-specie transfers.
When can a transfer occur?
A common misconception is that pension transfers can only occur before retirement. In reality, pension rights can generally be transferred before or after being crystallised, and at any age, subject to scheme rules. There is no minimum age for transferring pension benefits and no upper age limit.
Members may transfer:
- Accumulated pension rights before benefits are accessed.
- Drawdown arrangements.
- Certain pensions already in payment.
The further a member progresses through the retirement journey, the more complex the transfer rules typically become.
For example, transferring an uncrystallised money purchase arrangement is generally straightforward. By contrast, transferring a drawdown fund, annuity or scheme pension requires compliance with additional legislative conditions designed to preserve the integrity of the existing benefit structure.
These additional rules help ensure that individuals cannot obtain unauthorised tax advantages merely by changing providers.
The transfer date
The legal transfer date is more important than many people realise. The transfer date is not necessarily the date cash reaches the receiving provider. Instead, it is the point at which there is a clear agreement that beneficial ownership of the pension rights has passed from one arrangement to another. This distinction can prove important in several situations.
For example:
- Determining which scheme is responsible for death benefits.
- Establishing responsibility for benefit administration.
- Assessing the impact of legislative changes that apply from a particular date.
- Determining which scheme is responsible for carrying out certain reporting requirements.
The transfer date is therefore a legal and factual question rather than simply an administrative milestone.
Transfers of drawdown pensions
Drawdown funds can be transferred, including:
- Flexi-access drawdown funds.
- Capped drawdown funds.
- Beneficiary drawdown arrangements.
However, the whole drawdown fund must be transferred. Partial transfers of a drawdown fund cannot be recognised transfers.
Other important points include:
- The transferred funds must move into a new arrangement – there must be no other funds transferred into that arrangement, nor prior rights within that arrangement.
- Existing drawdown status is generally preserved.
- Historic capped drawdown calculations continue following transfer unless the member actively converts to flexi-access drawdown. This requires capped drawdown details to be provided to the receiving scheme.
Clients with drawdown plans are still able to consolidate their pensions into a single scheme but will generally hold a number of arrangements within that scheme. This can result in a number of plans within a single pension, commonly SIPP’s, each invested and administered separately.
Protections and transfer considerations
Before a transfer proceeds, it is important to establish whether any valuable rights, guarantees or protections could be lost. While a transfer may provide access to different investments, lower charges or greater flexibility, the receiving scheme may not replicate the benefits available under the existing arrangement.
Particular care is required when reviewing older pension contracts and occupational schemes, where valuable guarantees and scheme-specific rights are more common.
Safeguarded benefits
Safeguarded benefits are broadly benefits that include a promise or guarantee regarding the level of pension income payable to the member or their beneficiaries. These benefits can be particularly valuable and are typically not reproduced in a receiving scheme.
Common examples include:
- Defined benefit (DB) pensions, where benefits are based on factors such as salary and length of service rather than investment performance.
- Guaranteed annuity rates (GARs), which can provide substantially higher levels of secure retirement income than are available in the current annuity market. These guarantees often only apply at specified ages and on particular terms.
- Deferred annuity contracts, where retirement benefits have already been secured with an insurer and are payable in the future.
- Guaranteed Minimum Pension (GMP) rights, which may form part of benefits accrued in contracted-out pension schemes and provide a guaranteed minimum level of pension.
Where safeguarded benefits within a scheme are valued at more than £30,000, legislation generally requires the member to obtain appropriate independent advice from an FCA-authorised adviser before a transfer can proceed. With the exception of transfers of GARs, the adviser must be a pension transfer specialist.
Note, abridged advice is insufficient to enable the transfer of safeguarded benefits.
Scheme specific protections
Transfers can also affect valuable pension protections, notably:
- Protected pension ages, where a member may be entitled to access benefits before normal minimum pension age. In some cases, protected pension ages can be retained on transfer, and in others protected pension ages are lost. Read our briefing on Pension Age for more details.
- Scheme-specific tax-free cash, individuals who had an entitlement to tax-free cash greater than 25% of the fund on 5 April 2006. This protection is typically lost on transfer unless part of a block transfer.
Other valuable benefits
Lifetime allowance protections held before 15 March 2023 are generally no longer lost through a protection cessation event – such as a transfer, however, enhanced protection and fixed protections registered after 15 March 2023 may be lost as a result of certain transfers.
Other valuable features that could be lost on transfer include:
- With-profits investments, which may include guaranteed growth rates, guaranteed fund values or entitlement to a terminal bonus. Transfers may also trigger a market value adjustment (MVA) or other exit penalties.
- Employer-related benefits, such as ongoing employer contributions, salary sacrifice arrangements, subsidised charges or other workplace pension features that would cease on leaving the scheme.
The existence of guarantees or protected benefits does not necessarily mean a transfer is unsuitable. However, the value of any benefits being surrendered should always be understood and assessed against the advantages offered by the receiving arrangement.
Transferring while in poor health
Where a member is in serious ill health when they transfer a pension from one scheme to another there may be an inheritance tax liability if they die within two years of the transfer.
HMRC's long-standing view has been that a transfer between pension schemes can constitute a transfer of value for Inheritance Tax (IHT) purposes. This applies even where both the transferring and receiving pension arrangements are themselves discretionary death benefit schemes that are typically outside the individual's estate. HMRC’s concern is that the transfer has increased the value of death benefits payable to beneficiaries (exempt from IHT) at the expense of the estate.
Where there is no indication of reduced life expectancy and the transfer is being undertaken for ordinary retirement planning or administrative reasons, IHT concerns are significantly less likely to arise.
From April 2027, most pension death benefits will form part of a member’s estate on their death, as such the significance of transfers in poor health will largely be removed. If anything, this change enables those in poor health to make decisions best in line with their goals without concern for the IHT risk, as the funds would likely be subject to IHT either way.
Cancellation rights
No cancellation right exists on a transfer – so once agreed, clients cannot generally choose to cancel the transfer instruction. However, cancellation rights within a cooling off period apply to new contracts – such as where clients setup a new pension arrangement to receive a transfer.
If the member exercises their right and cancels a new contract within the cooling-off period any transferred funds should be returned to the original pension scheme. However, this does not guarantee that any rights and benefits the client held within that scheme (in the previous arrangement) will automatically be reinstated. Providers may instead look to process a transfer to a new scheme of the members choice, or otherwise look for the client to setup a new plan within the scheme so those funds can be effectively administered. This can be particularly problematic for closed book providers or those who do not have permissions to sell new plans.
Transfers into schemes where cancellation rights have already lapsed will not be able to be cancelled.